This short riddle trips people up because two answers seem to fit. Here’s the riddle, the best answer and why, and 10 more riddles in the same style.
Quick answer: bait (the worm on a fishhook).
Contents
- The Riddle
- Answer and Explanation
- 10 More Tricky Food Riddles
- More Riddle Collections
- Frequently Asked Questions
The Riddle
“First you eat me, then you get eaten. What am I?”

Answer and Explanation
Read the riddle from the fish’s point of view. First the fish eats the bait. Then the fish is caught – and gets eaten by the fisherman.
Bait or fishhook? Both answers are accepted. “Bait” fits best, because the bait is what the fish actually eats. Many quiz apps list “fishhook”, because the bait sits on the hook and the fish swallows both. If your game rejects one, try the other.
10 More Tricky Food Riddles
Liked that one? Try these – the answers are hidden until you click.
1. What has to be broken before you can use it?
Show answer
Answer: An egg.
2. What two things can you never eat for breakfast?
Show answer
Lunch and dinner. Full answer
3. I’m tall when I’m young and short when I’m old. What am I?
Show answer
Answer: A candle.
4. What kind of room has no doors or windows?
Show answer
Answer: A mushroom.
5. What gets eaten before it’s born and after it’s dead?
Show answer
Answer: An egg – eaten before it hatches, and the chicken is eaten later.
6. What has many eyes but can’t see?
Show answer
Answer: A potato.
7. What is yellow, long and has a peel you can slip on?
Show answer
Answer: A banana.
8. What do you throw away the outside, cook the inside, eat the outside and throw away the inside?
Show answer
Corn on the cob.
9. The more I eat, the hungrier I get. What am I?
Show answer
Fire. Full answer
10. What fruit never ever wants to be alone?
Show answer
Answer: A pear (pair).
More Riddle Collections
- 40 What Am I Riddles
- 1000+ Easy Riddles with Answers
- 50 Hardest Riddles in the World
- Riddle of the Day – a new riddle every day
- हिंदी पहेलियाँ (Hindi Riddles)
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the answer to “First you eat me, then you get eaten”?
Bait – the fish eats the bait, then the fish gets caught and eaten. “Fishhook” is also accepted.
Is the answer bait or fishhook?
Both work. Bait is what the fish eats; the hook holds the bait. Most riddle books say bait.
Who gets eaten in the riddle?
The fish – it eats the bait first and is then eaten by the person who caught it.